Are Social Media Sharing Buttons Helping or Hurting Your Small Business Website's Visibility?



Social Share

With the proliferation of social media sharing buttons on websites, one might assume they are crucial for boosting visibility. However, the reality is not always so clear-cut. Small business owners must consider whether these buttons truly enhance their website‘s visibility or if they inadvertently hinder it. In this article, we will research into the potential benefits and drawbacks of social media sharing buttons and provide insights to help you make an informed decision for your small business’s online presence.

Key Takeaways:

  • Social media sharing buttons can hurt your small business website’s visibility: While it may seem counterintuitive, cluttering your website with social media sharing buttons can actually distract visitors from your main content and slow down your site’s loading speed, negatively impacting your search engine ranking.
  • Focus on high-quality content over social sharing buttons: Instead of relying solely on social media buttons, prioritize creating engaging and valuable content that naturally encourages users to share it. Quality content is more likely to attract organic sharing and boost your website’s visibility.
  • Strategically place social sharing buttons for maximum impact: If you choose to include social sharing buttons on your small business website, place them strategically where they will be noticed but not overpowering. Tailor the selection of social platforms based on your target audience’s preferences to maximize sharing potential.

The Rise of Social Media Sharing Buttons

The Promise of Increased Visibility

Buttons have become a staple feature on websites, promising increased visibility and engagement with just a click. Small businesses are enticed by the idea that adding these buttons will make it easier for visitors to share their content across various social media platforms. The promise of expanded reach through the simple act of clicking a button is appealing and seems like a straightforward way to boost online presence.

The Ubiquity of Sharing Buttons on Websites

Promise the ubiquity of sharing buttons on websites has skyrocketed in recent years. It’s rare to visit a site that doesn’t feature a row of colorful icons beckoning you to share content with your network. These buttons have become so prevalent that we often don’t think twice about their presence – they’re just expected to be there. However, this proliferation raises questions about their effectiveness and potential drawbacks.

The Dark Side of Social Media Sharing Buttons

Some Incorporating Social Media Sharing Buttons on your small business website can have unintended consequences. While they offer the potential for increased visibility, there are drawbacks to consider as well.

Distractions and Decreased Engagement

Social media sharing buttons, while intended to encourage visitors to share your content, can actually be distractions. Instead of focusing on the valuable information on your website, visitors may be drawn to these buttons, decreasing engagement with your actual content. This can lead to missed opportunities for conversions or important actions on your site.

Slower Load Times and Performance Issues

Sharing social media sharing buttons can also contribute to slower load times and performance issues on your website. The more plugins and widgets you add for sharing buttons, the more HTTP requests are made, which can slow down your site. A slow-loading site not only affects user experience but can also impact your search engine rankings, as site speed is a ranking factor considered by search engines like Google.

The Impact on Search Engine Optimization (SEO)

How Sharing Buttons Affect Page Rankings

The integration of social media sharing buttons on your small business website can have a significant impact on your search engine optimization efforts. Unlike traditional backlinks, social signals from platforms like Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram can positively influence your website’s visibility in search engine results pages.

When visitors engage with your content through social sharing, it sends a signal to search engines that your website is valuable and relevant. This can lead to improved search engine rankings and increased organic traffic. However, it’s vital to consider the quality and relevance of the shared content, as excessive or irrelevant social signals could potentially harm your SEO efforts.

The Role of Social Signals in SEO

For small businesses looking to enhance their SEO strategy, leveraging social signals can be a powerful tool. Search engines like Google consider the number of likes, shares, comments, and social media engagement as indicators of a website’s credibility and authority.

The Effect on User Experience

Cluttered Design and Visual Overload

User experience is crucial when it comes to a small business website’s success. Having an abundance of social media sharing buttons cluttering your pages can negatively impact how visitors engage with your content. A cluttered design can overwhelm users, leading to confusion and frustration. It can distract visitors from your main call-to-action and vital information, ultimately driving them away from your site.

The Importance of Clean Design and Minimalism

For a more positive user experience, it is vital to prioritize clean design and minimalism on your website. A minimalist approach can help improve readability, guide users’ focus to key elements, and enhance overall user satisfaction. By decluttering your pages and removing excessive social media sharing buttons, you can create a more visually appealing and user-friendly website.

Designing with a focus on simplicity and functionality can also improve site speed and performance, which are key factors for both user experience and search engine optimization (SEO). By streamlining your design and only including necessary elements, you can create a more efficient and effective website for your small business.

The Benefits of Strategic Button Placement

After integrating social media sharing buttons on your small business website, the key to maximizing their effectiveness lies in strategic placement. By positioning these buttons thoughtfully, you can enhance visibility without compromising user experience (UX).

Maximizing Visibility without Sacrificing UX

Maximizing the visibility of social media sharing buttons is crucial for increasing the reach of your content. However, it’s vital to find a balance that doesn’t overwhelm visitors or detract from the overall user experience. Placing these buttons prominently yet tastefully on your web pages can encourage visitors to share your content with their networks, driving more traffic to your site. Note, a cluttered layout can confuse users and lead to a high bounce rate, so strategically placing these buttons is key.

Best Practices for Button Placement and Design

Any successful small business website knows that the design and placement of social media sharing buttons can make a significant impact on engagement levels. For instance, incorporating these buttons near the top or bottom of your content can increase visibility while ensuring they don’t disrupt the reading experience. Additionally, choosing a design that aligns with your brand aesthetics can make these buttons more appealing and encourage users to click and share.

Alternatives to Traditional Sharing Buttons

The Rise of Native Sharing Features

All too often, small businesses clutter their websites with traditional social media sharing buttons in an attempt to increase visibility. However, the rise of native sharing features on popular platforms like Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram has made these traditional buttons somewhat obsolete. With native sharing features, visitors can easily share content directly from the platform they are already logged into, without the need for extra buttons on your website.

Innovative Approaches to Social Sharing

The landscape of social media sharing is constantly evolving, and small businesses need to keep up with innovative approaches to stay ahead. Some companies have found success by incorporating social sharing functionality directly into their website’s design, creating a seamless and visually appealing way for users to share content. Others have taken a more personalized approach, utilizing tools that allow users to share content with specific individuals or groups, rather than broadcasting it to their entire network.

For example, one innovative approach could involve implementing a “share with a friend” button that allows users to privately send a link or content to someone they think would find it valuable. This not only encourages more targeted sharing but also creates a more personal connection between users and your brand.


To wrap up

Now that we’ve explored the role of social media sharing buttons on your small business website’s visibility, it’s clear that while these buttons can offer some benefits in terms of increasing social engagement, they may not have a significant impact on your site’s overall visibility. It’s crucial to strike a balance and consider the potential drawbacks such as slower page load times and cluttered design. Ultimately, focusing on high-quality content and strategic SEO efforts might prove to be more beneficial for improving your website’s visibility in the long run.

As with any aspect of digital marketing, it’s crucial to approach social media sharing buttons with a critical eye and weigh the pros and cons for your specific business needs. Experimentation and monitoring analytics can help you determine the effectiveness of these buttons on your website and make informed decisions to optimize your online presence. Note, in the fast-paced world of online marketing, adaptability and continuous improvement are key to staying ahead of the curve and maximizing your small business’s visibility.


Q: Do social media sharing buttons help or hurt small business website visibility?

A: Social media sharing buttons can both help and hurt small business website visibility. While these buttons make it easy for visitors to share content and potentially reach a broader audience, they can also slow down website loading speed and clutter the user interface, potentially turning visitors away.

Q: How can small businesses optimize the use of social media sharing buttons on their website?

A: Small businesses can optimize the use of social media sharing buttons by strategically placing them in prominent locations on the webpage, ensuring they do not interfere with the overall user experience. It’s also important to regularly monitor the performance of these buttons and adjust their placement or design based on visitor behavior.

Q: What are some alternative strategies small businesses can use to boost website visibility besides social media sharing buttons?

A: Small businesses can boost website visibility by creating high-quality, shareable content, engaging with their audience on social media platforms, optimizing their website for search engines, and collaborating with influencers or industry partners for cross-promotion. These strategies can help increase organic traffic and improve overall online visibility.


Chat with us

Wanna hop on discord? Let's tackle the problem.

  • Discreet and Professional
  • No obligation consulation

No spam. I don't even have a mailing list.